The kids who live with their parents on Alcatraz are in a very unsual living environment. Do YOU think that Alcatraz would make a good place for a kid to grow up? Why or why not?? In your post tell us your opinion, and make sure you give us some good reasons to support it.
I have to admit, it is interesting to consider living on Alcatraz. I really think though that it is not the best environment for children. Murderers, kidnappers, and other criminals are not who I would want to live around!
ReplyDeleteI disagree becasue it would not be that bad becasue you would never see them !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ReplyDeletei think that no little kids should grow up on alcatraz. i think that because the criminals there the people who could take them or hurt them thats my comment
ReplyDeletei thake it would be cool to live there
ReplyDeleteIt might be pretty cool.Alcatraz is a cool but freaky place.
ReplyDeleteI like this book because it is interesting to see how the kids live there and every body else who lives there.
ReplyDeleteNO! Alcatraz would not be a good place for a kid to grow up. Cause there r no good role modles
ReplyDeleteI like this book because it tells alot about how kids lived on the island, how people got there, and why it is hard to escape from there
ReplyDeleteno because there are murders and kidnappers anthe worlds most deadliest convics it maybe awsome but i dont think so other kids may think so but i dont because they could escape and then kill not only us but they could kill other people
ReplyDeleteHolly, what about the guards? Would you consider them good role models?
ReplyDeleteyes! because they would get taught self discipline and would learn respect for others.
ReplyDeleteNo, Becuase there are crimnals and bad people there that could escape.. and they could get you... IN UR SLLEP O: or just say you were out wakinn they coukd attack you.. idk but its not a good place to kee kids arondd(: BYE:D
ReplyDeleteNikki... I LOVE MY BESITEE MALINDA :D I LOVEE HER AND HER LONG HAIR O.O
No because their are crimanles every were and if they got out they could hurt you.
ReplyDeleteI think it would be a bad place but then on the other hand it would not be that bad because the kids might be more calm and respectful and kind. :0)
ReplyDeleteI think it is NOT a good place for a kid to grow up because there are bad people there.also it would make the kid scared and it might effect there lifes because you might come home and your kid has killed some one... and that is why i think it is a bad place to live!!!!!!!!!
ReplyDeleteI think it would NOT be a good place for kids to live on Alcatraz!Because 1: first of all who would not be completely mad because you would be looking at tha beeaauutiful water front and yet girls aint allow to swim in itt!!!(The warden didnt allow girls to wear bikinies!!lol)
ReplyDelete:}
No it is not a good place for people even kidss to live because they couldd get hurt or kidnapped and it is just not a good inverment
ReplyDeleteNO because if you lived on Alcatraz you could get mugged or somethan and if a criminal gets loose they can sneek into your house and stabb you :(and that would hurt!!!!Another reason is there are to many rules to follow!BYEEEE:)MY BESTIE IS NIKKI AND SHE AWSOMENESS
ReplyDeletepartyboy said...............................
ReplyDeletehe thinks yes beacuse it will show you respect
to other people.
I think growing up on alcatraz would not be fun at all because one of the crimanals could escape witch would be dangerous !!!!!!!!!!!!!:)
ReplyDeleteI think Alcatraz would be a bad place to live because their would be a bad influence on you when you get older.
ReplyDeleteI think it would be a good place to learn respect.
ReplyDeleteIt would be awsome so you know who the big daddys are in the world!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ReplyDeleteno it is dangerous.
ReplyDeleteI dont think that would be a good place for kids to grow up there because there are criminals there.
ReplyDeleteNO!!!!!!!! Because there's bad people on the islan and you might get...........KILLED
ReplyDeleteNO! BECAUSE (ALCATRAZ)IS A PRISON FOR CONVIC'S.
ReplyDeleteJacob here; i agree with tyler you'd never even meet them.Even if you did there are guards everywhere.you'd never be in danger.
ReplyDeleteI think it would be creepy
ReplyDeleteLOL[>_<]emodacon
I think it would NOT be a good place for kids to live on Alcatraz!Because 1: first of all who would not be completely mad because you would be looking at tha beeaauutiful water front and yet girls aint allow to swim in itt!!!(The warden didnt allow girls to wear bikinies!!lol)
ReplyDelete:}
aaaahhh dont now it could be good or bad
ReplyDeleteNO!!!!!! this is Ryan and I agree with Tyler it whould stink to live there you don't get to do anything and there are criminals and you don't get to see any of them
ReplyDeleteI think it would be a little frightning but if there were kids there it would make it more funner than it sounds but i would have to say NO!! (:-D
ReplyDeleteI don`t think Alcatraz would be all that bad of a place to live at,because in the book it says it is safer than San Fransisco so it sounds pretty safe to me.
ReplyDeleteNice comment hip hop
ReplyDeletei think it would be fun
ReplyDeletehip-hop said................................
ReplyDeleteit............... would..........be..............awsome............yeah!!!!!!!!!!!!!
NO! I dont think that AlCatraz would be a good place for kids to grow up at,because there are kid nappers and bad people there.
ReplyDeleteMicheal Ann says...I do not think it would be healthy to grown up in Alcatraz. Most kids would probably feel insecure-like an escapee might break in their home or be hiding around the corner waiting to hold them for ransome in exchange for their freedom. I also think it would make a kid feel depressed because of the bad things that would go on around them-inmates on death row, fights all the time, and being surrounded by mostly mean people.
ReplyDeleteI do not think Alcatraz would not be a good place to live for a kid. It would be a bad place because if a prisoner broke out the they might hurt someone.
ReplyDeleteI like Al Capone does my shoes because it be cool to live on Alcatraz being close to prisoners.
ReplyDelete